The Court of Appeal has handed down an important decision in the case of (1) Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd (2) Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.2 Limited v De Valk and others [2026] EWCA Civ 1466, and provided further clarity on the impact of Paragraph 8 to Schedule 8 of the Building Safety Act 2022 (“BSA”) relating to the recoverability of service charges.
The judgment will be of particular interest to freeholders, managing agents and qualifying leaseholders where a building requires cladding remediation.
The case concerned remediation works at Centre Point House. It stands next to Centre Point Tower, a prominent building that you are likely to have seen if you have been in the vicinity of Tottenham Court Road.
Paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 sets out that qualifying leaseholders will not have to pay service charges with regards to “cladding remediation”. Other protections in Schedule 8 are limited to “relevant defects”, however there is no express mention of relevant defects in Paragraph 8, unlike in Paragraphs 2-7. The Court interpreted that leaving out the words “relevant defects” was Parliament’s intention and that it should be interpretated separately to the other paragraphs.
The practical effect is that qualifying leaseholders may not be required to pay service charge where it does not fall within the definition of Relevant Defect (as defined in s.120 BSA 2022). This is relevant as it is not therefore limited to the Relevant Period of 30 years prior to 28 June 2022. Whilst the First Tier Tribunal in Secretary of State for Housing and Communities and Local Government v Canary Riverside Estate Management Limited & Ors [2026] determined as a preliminary issue a relatively low threshold exists in relation to Relevant Defects, the decision in Almacantar will be important for those Buildings where cladding remediation is required for an external wall outside the 30 year period.
The Court went on to consider the definition of “unsafe” at paragraph 8 and whether it related solely to fire safety concerns. The Appellants had argued that “unsafe” means combustible or fire-related, stressing that the BSA had only been enacted as a response to the Grenfell Tower tragedy.
In favour of Leaseholders, the Court ruled that “unsafe” does not merely relate to fire safety concerns or combustible cladding but found that “unsafe” is an ordinary English word which, read naturally, simply signifies “involving danger” and nothing in Paragraph 8 restricts its definition to fire risks. The Court affirmed that the BSA was by no means exclusively concerned with fire risks. This means that, where cladding presents a danger for reasons other than fire, the protection for leaseholders from being liable for service charge may still apply.
How we can help
How can we help?
We advise freeholders, managing agents/companies and qualifying leaseholders on the Building Safety Act 2022 and on service charge recovery more generally. If you have any issues regarding the recovery or challenge of service charges, our team can assist in providing you with advice on your position in the law and the next steps available to you.
For advice on Building Safety Act disputes, service charge recovery, and the rights of qualifying leaseholders, please contact Meaby & Co at info@meaby.co.uk or on 020 7703 5034.